Indianapolis is a city full of surprises, with more to offer than meets the eye. Beyond the well-known attractions and bustling areas, Indy is home to a variety of hidden gems that many locals would prefer to keep under wraps. These lesser-known spots offer unique experiences, from cozy cafes to tucked-away green spaces, and are perfect for those looking to explore a side of the city that most visitors miss. Here’s a look at some of Indy’s best-kept secrets that locals don’t want you to know about.
1. LUNA Music
Tucked away in the Broad Ripple neighborhood, LUNA Music is more than just a record store—it’s a haven for vinyl enthusiasts and indie music lovers. While many flock to larger music stores in the city, LUNA offers a curated selection of records, from classic rock to the latest indie releases, alongside hard-to-find limited editions and music memorabilia. With its chill vibe, in-store events, and knowledgeable staff, it’s the perfect spot for digging through crates and discovering new sounds.
Location: 5202 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
2. Locally Grown Gardens
You wouldn’t expect to find a quaint farm-to-table experience tucked into a small stretch of shops along 54th Street, but that’s exactly what Locally Grown Gardens offers. This hidden oasis combines a local market, restaurant, and garden, serving fresh pies, local produce, and an array of seasonal dishes. The picnic-style seating invites you to sit and enjoy a simple, delicious meal surrounded by greenery, making it feel like a mini escape from the city.
Location: 1050 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN
3. Funkyard Coffee Shop & Gallery
For those in the know, Funkyard in Irvington is a quirky gem that combines a funky coffee shop vibe with a gallery showcasing local art. This neighborhood spot is beloved for its eclectic decor, comfortable seating, and rotating art displays. The shop serves up delicious lattes and cold brews, making it a perfect spot to work or catch up with friends. Don’t miss their patio, a colorful, peaceful spot to enjoy your coffee on warmer days.
Location: 1114 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN
4. Holliday Park’s Ruins
While Holliday Park is a well-loved public park known for its nature trails and playground, the true hidden gem lies within—The Ruins. These fascinating structures feature old architectural remnants from New York City’s St. Paul Building, reassembled into a unique art installation. The columns, statues, and gardens create a beautiful, almost surreal setting that feels more like an ancient site than a Midwest park. It’s a perfect spot for a quiet walk, photography, or a little reflection time in nature.
Location: 6363 Spring Mill Rd, Indianapolis, IN
5. Twenty Tap
Beer lovers flock to the larger breweries around Indy, but those in the know head to Twenty Tap, a neighborhood gem located in the heart of SoBro (South Broad Ripple). This unassuming gastropub boasts an impressive selection of 38 rotating craft beers on tap, many from local breweries. But it’s not just the drinks that make Twenty Tap special—their menu is full of delicious pub fare, including their famous burgers and inventive vegetarian options. It’s the kind of place locals want to keep to themselves.
Location: 5406 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
6. The Indianapolis Artsgarden
Most people in Indy know of the Indianapolis Artsgarden as an iconic glass dome that hovers over the intersection of Washington and Illinois Streets. But many overlook it as a unique venue for free live performances, art exhibitions, and cultural events. The space often hosts local musicians, dance performances, and art displays, making it a surprising and intimate cultural escape right in the heart of downtown.
Location: 110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
7. Repeal Restaurant
Hidden within the historic Fletcher Place neighborhood, Repeal is a speakeasy-style restaurant that pays homage to the Prohibition era with craft cocktails and delicious comfort food. Its unassuming exterior makes it easy to miss, but inside you’ll find vintage decor, dim lighting, and a menu filled with creative cocktails and hearty meals, including their signature burger. For those in the know, Repeal is the perfect spot to grab a drink and dinner away from the busier downtown scene.
Location: 630 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
8. Indiana Medical History Museum
For something truly off the beaten path, Indiana Medical History Museum offers an eerie yet fascinating look into the state’s medical past. Housed in the former pathology building of the Central State Hospital, this hidden museum showcases old medical equipment, preserved specimens, and an authentic autopsy room. It’s a glimpse into the evolution of medicine in Indiana, with tours that dive into the history of mental health and medical research. A visit here is an unforgettable experience, far removed from Indy’s typical tourist spots.
Location: 3045 W Vermont St, Indianapolis, IN
9. Landlocked Music
Broad Ripple is home to some of Indy’s coolest spots, and Landlocked Music is no exception. This independent record store is a hidden gem for music lovers, offering a wide selection of new and used vinyl, CDs, and even cassettes. It’s the kind of place where you can discover new releases from local artists, browse classic albums, and find rare or limited-edition records. Landlocked is a music lover’s paradise, tucked away from the hustle of bigger commercial stores.
Location: 202 N College Ave, Bloomington, IN (temporary relocated)
10. Flat12 Bierwerks
While many breweries in Indy are well-known, Flat12 Bierwerks remains a more under-the-radar spot for craft beer lovers. Located just east of downtown, this small brewery is known for its creative, seasonal brews and relaxed atmosphere. Whether you’re enjoying their year-round offerings like the Upside Down Blonde or trying one of their limited-edition experimental brews, Flat12 offers an authentic, laid-back brewery experience. Their dog-friendly outdoor patio makes it a perfect spot to enjoy a beer with your four-legged friend.
Location: 414 Dorman St, Indianapolis, IN
These hidden gems showcase a different side of Indianapolis, offering unique and intimate experiences you won’t find on most tourist maps. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these lesser-known spots offer a fresh perspective on the Circle City and are well worth exploring.
theindyobserver.com 