Indianapolis may be famous for its iconic race track and sports venues, but beneath the surface lies a rich tapestry of culinary treasures waiting to be discovered. While the city’s food scene often highlights the big names, there are countless hidden gems offering flavors that will surprise and delight even the most seasoned foodie. From family-owned eateries to innovative fusion spots, here are some of the city’s underrated restaurants you need to try.

1. Bluebeard

Nestled in the historic Fletcher Place neighborhood, Bluebeard offers a dining experience that feels both nostalgic and modern. This charming spot, housed in a 1924 factory warehouse, serves up farm-to-table dishes that change with the seasons. While their house-made charcuterie and artisan bread are favorites, the standout is the ever-evolving menu, featuring everything from braised short ribs to heirloom tomato salads. For those who appreciate an intimate, cozy setting with impeccable food, Bluebeard is a must.

2. King Dough

Pizza lovers rejoice! King Dough, located in the heart of downtown Indy, is the place for artisanal, wood-fired pies that go beyond your average slice. Using locally sourced ingredients, King Dough crafts innovative pizzas like the “Bee Sting” with spicy soppressata, honey, and fresh basil. The warm, rustic interior and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a laid-back night out or a weekend brunch.

3. Milktooth

Milktooth is an all-day brunch spot that has garnered national attention but remains a lesser-known gem among locals. Set in an old auto repair shop, the atmosphere is quirky and fun, making it a fantastic backdrop for the creative dishes served up. Don’t miss the sourdough Dutch baby pancake topped with seasonal fruits and house-made ricotta or their signature pork belly bánh mì. If you’re seeking a culinary adventure with an edge, Milktooth is the place to be.

4. La Parada

Craving authentic Mexican cuisine? Head over to La Parada, a humble, family-run establishment that offers some of the best tacos and tamales in town. The menu is straightforward but packed with flavor—think al pastor tacos, chicken mole, and hand-pressed corn tortillas. The unassuming exterior hides a gem for those looking for an authentic and affordable dining experience that’s big on flavor and heart.

5. Livery

For a taste of Latin America in the heart of Indianapolis, Livery is an absolute must. Located in a former horse stable, the ambiance is both rustic and vibrant, perfectly matching its menu of bold flavors. Standouts include their empanadas, Argentine chimichurri steak, and the mouthwatering paella. Their rooftop seating is ideal for warm evenings, providing an urban oasis perfect for date nights or casual gatherings.

6. Yats

Comfort food enthusiasts will feel right at home at Yats, a small local chain specializing in Cajun and Creole dishes. With locations scattered across Indy, Yats offers heaping portions of dishes like jambalaya, étouffée, and gumbo—all served over rice with a side of buttery bread. The best part? The affordable prices make it easy to try multiple dishes. The no-frills, counter-service style keeps things casual, but the food is anything but ordinary.

7. Rook

For lovers of Asian-inspired cuisine, Rook in the Fletcher Place neighborhood is a gem often overshadowed by more prominent Asian restaurants in the city. Their menu offers a modern twist on street food classics, including bao buns stuffed with crispy pork belly, duck ramen bowls, and their famous kimchi fries. The cozy, industrial-chic setting is perfect for a casual dinner or a night out with friends who appreciate adventurous flavors.

8. Tlaolli

Tlaolli may be a small, unassuming spot, but it packs a punch with its authentic Mexican offerings. Specializing in tamales and fresh, homemade dishes, Tlaolli offers an impressive array of vegetarian and vegan options alongside their meat-centric counterparts. From the tangy jackfruit tacos to their chicken mole tamales, each dish feels like a celebration of traditional flavors with a modern twist. A favorite for takeout, it’s the perfect way to bring a taste of Mexico to your table.

9. Root & Bone

If you’re looking for Southern comfort food with a twist, Root & Bone is your go-to. Tucked away on a quiet street, this spot serves up elevated Southern classics like fried chicken with honey-tabasco sauce, shrimp and grits, and their signature mac and cheese. The restaurant’s modern rustic decor and warm lighting create an inviting space that feels like a Southern grandmother’s kitchen—if she had a flair for plating Instagram-worthy dishes.

10. The Inferno Room

Rounding off our list is The Inferno Room, a tiki bar that doubles as an underrated dining spot for adventurous eaters. With a menu of Polynesian-inspired dishes and a quirky, immersive atmosphere filled with tropical decor, it’s a must-visit for anyone looking to escape the ordinary. Standout dishes include their coconut shrimp skewers, Hawaiian poke bowls, and rum-glazed ribs. Pair your meal with one of their colorful, tiki-themed cocktails for a night that feels like a mini vacation.

Final Thoughts

Indianapolis may not always get the recognition it deserves as a foodie destination, but with these hidden gems, it’s clear the city is home to a vibrant, diverse culinary scene. Whether you’re a long-time local or a visitor passing through, these underrated spots are worth the detour. So next time you’re in the Circle City, skip the chains and try something new—Indy’s hidden food gems are waiting!