In the heart of Indianapolis, where the craft beer scene and artisan cocktails reign supreme, there’s a quieter, more mysterious side to nightlife that’s emerging in the form of hidden speakeasies. These secret spots are tucked away behind unmarked doors, beneath bustling streets, or inside seemingly ordinary establishments—giving those who seek them an exclusive taste of the Prohibition-era vibe. If you’re up for a little adventure and want to experience Indy’s more elusive nightlife, here’s a guide to the city’s best hidden speakeasies.

1. The Inferno Room

Located in the heart of Broad Ripple, The Inferno Room offers a tiki twist on the traditional speakeasy. You’ll enter through an unassuming back alley, but inside, you’re greeted with Polynesian décor and tropical vibes that make you feel like you’ve stepped out of Indianapolis and into an exotic island bar. Known for their rum-based cocktails and elaborate tiki mugs, this is the perfect spot for those who love a tropical escape. Pro tip: their Mai Tai is a must-try!

2. The Ball & Biscuit

While The Ball & Biscuit is technically a popular cocktail bar, it holds a hidden secret. Behind its familiar, cozy facade on Mass Ave lies an exclusive private room reserved for patrons in the know. This area, often referred to as the “backroom,” offers a quieter, more intimate atmosphere. Access is by reservation only, so be sure to call ahead if you want a spot in this secret space.

3. Thunderbird’s Basement Lounge

In the trendy Fountain Square district, Thunderbird is known for its expertly crafted cocktails and Southern-inspired menu, but few people realize there’s more to this establishment. Head downstairs to the basement, where a dimly lit speakeasy-style lounge awaits. With velvet couches, low lighting, and a rotating cocktail menu featuring house-made ingredients, it’s the perfect spot for a low-key night out.

4. The Vault at The Exchange Whiskey Bar

As the name suggests, this speakeasy is housed in a former bank vault, hidden beneath the main level of The Exchange Whiskey Bar downtown. To find it, you’ll need to ask your server for entry, as access is restricted to those in the know. Once inside, you’ll be treated to a more exclusive experience, with a menu focused on rare whiskeys and high-end cocktails. The brick walls and steel door create a distinctly vintage ambiance that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time.

5. Bar One Fourteen

If you blink, you might miss Bar One Fourteen. Tucked away in the Meridian-Kessler neighborhood, this intimate 14-seat speakeasy is hidden behind an unmarked black door. The bar’s minimalist, dark aesthetic is paired with creative cocktails and a menu that changes regularly. Its exclusivity, limited seating, and unique mix of drinks make this one of the most elusive bars in Indy—and one you won’t want to miss if you’re looking for a chic, private experience.

Finding Indy’s Hidden Gems

While speakeasies may have their origins in the secret bars of the Prohibition era, today, they offer a stylish and intriguing way to enjoy an exclusive night out. These hidden gems of Indianapolis provide a refreshing break from the ordinary bar scene, offering you a chance to step back in time—or simply enjoy a more intimate, tailored drinking experience. So next time you’re out in Indy and feel like doing a bit of exploring, seek out one of these secret spots. Just remember: part of the fun is in the discovery.

Looking for more speakeasies or hidden gems in Indy? Keep an eye on The Indy Observer for updates on the latest in the Circle City’s nightlife!